They should have been huge, riding the ATG sound so well and all. Just to see the American metalcore scene replicate this whole thing a couple years after.
I've got a whole load of flacs and since I listen to music with fairly good headphoney, it definitely makea a difference in sound. Might matter more with some bands than others, but it's still "enhanced" and deeper, no matter which band.
For me, this band is almost good but not quite enough. Every 5 or so years I give them another chance, but it doesn't last long. Every moment feels like something good is coming... surely something interesting is about to happen, but nothing does. Every riff feels like its leading to something bigger, but then it just repeats an earlier, equally mediocre part. Its all way too tame. Even the solo is just like "yeah this is a solo, or whatever".
The Everdawn, I'll drop in to say hi in another 5 - 7 years. Or whatever.